List of Artists Suing the Copyright Law at the Constitutional Court, from Armand Maulana to Raisa

A total of 29 Indonesian musicians have officially filed a lawsuit against Law Number 28 of 2014 concerning Copyright at the Constitutional Court (MK). These musicians are requesting a material test of the regulation as it is deemed to provide inadequate protection for creators and players in the music industry.

The lawsuit is registered under case number 33/PUU/PAN.MK/AP3/03/2025. The applicants come from various musical backgrounds, ranging from band vocalists, pop soloists, to independent musicians actively involved in the creative industry in the country.

This step is not a sudden action. Some of them had previously met with the Ministry of Law and Human Rights (Kemenkumham) three weeks earlier to discuss the disparities in the current copyright regulations.

1. Musicians Who Filed a Lawsuit with the Constitutional Court

List of Artists Who Sued the Copyright Law to the Constitutional Court (credit: instagram/armandmaulana04)

A total of 29 musicians from various music genres have filed a lawsuit against the Copyright Law. Among them are Armand Maulana, Ariel NOAH, Raisa, Judika, Bunga Citra Lestari, Rossa, and Nadin Amizah. Additionally, other musicians such as Bernadya, Afgan, Andien, Ruth Sahanaya, David Naif, and Rendy Pandugo also participated in this lawsuit.

The participation of these musicians shows that copyright issues are not only experienced by one or two individuals, but have become a significant issue in the Indonesian music industry. They feel that the current regulations do not provide optimal protection for creators and players in the music industry. Therefore, they agreed to bring this issue to the Constitutional Court.

2. Reasons Musicians Sue the Copyright Law

List of Artists Who Filed a Copyright Law Lawsuit to the Constitutional Court (credit: instagram/arielnoah)

Musicians believe that several articles in the Copyright Law are still weak in providing legal certainty regarding the economic rights of song creators and singers. They feel that the existing regulations benefit music labels and distribution platforms more than the song creators themselves.

In addition, they feel that the current royalty mechanism is not transparent and fair enough. Many musicians struggle to obtain economic rights for their works due to a system that does not favor the creators. Therefore, they are requesting the Constitutional Court to review certain articles in the Copyright Law to make it fairer for musicians.

3. Steps Taken by Musicians Before Filing a Lawsuit

List of Artists Who Sued the Copyright Law to the Constitutional Court (credit: instagram/raisa6690)

Before officially filing a lawsuit to the Constitutional Court, these musicians have made various efforts to voice their dissatisfaction with the existing Copyright Law. One of the initial steps they took was to hold a meeting with the Ministry of Law and Human Rights about three weeks before the lawsuit was filed. In that meeting, they expressed their concerns and provided input regarding copyright regulations that are considered to not provide optimal protection for creators.

In addition, the musicians also held internal discussions and consolidated with fellow music industry players. They sought to gather various perspectives and input to strengthen their arguments in the lawsuit. After careful consideration, they ultimately decided to bring this issue to the Constitutional Court to obtain better legal certainty.

4. Musicians' Hopes Regarding This Lawsuit

List of Artists Who Sued the Copyright Law at the Constitutional Court (credit: instagram/bernadyaribka)

By filing a lawsuit to the Constitutional Court, musicians hope for a revision of the problematic articles in the Copyright Law. They want regulations that favor creators and musicians, not just large industries like record labels and streaming platforms.

In addition, they also hope that the royalty distribution mechanism can be more transparent and fair. With a clearer system, musicians can receive economic rights that correspond to the works they produce. If this lawsuit is granted, the Indonesian music industry has the potential to undergo better changes in terms of copyright protection and royalty distribution.

5. The Impact of This Lawsuit on the Indonesian Music Industry

If the Constitutional Court accepts this lawsuit and revises the Copyright Law, the Indonesian music industry could undergo significant changes, particularly in the royalty distribution system and copyright protection. One of the impacts is a fairer royalty distribution for musicians, allowing them to receive more reasonable economic rights.

Additionally, this revision could also change the contract mechanisms between artists and record labels, making the working relationship between them more transparent and mutually beneficial. However, if this lawsuit is rejected, the existing regulations will continue as they are now, and it is likely that musicians will seek other ways to fight for their rights, whether through legislative channels or other advocacy methods.

6. Why are musicians suing the Copyright Law at the Constitutional Court?

They believe that the current regulations do not provide fair protection for song creators and musicians in the distribution of royalties.

7. What is meant by judicial review at the Constitutional Court?

Judicial review is a legal process in which the Constitutional Court assesses whether a law contradicts the 1945 Constitution.

Want to read more news? Let's read now at KapanLagi.com. If not now, when?

(kpl/sjn)