Melly Goeslaw Speaks Out Regarding the Viral Band Sukatani, Supports Creative Freedom Wisely

The band Sukatani suddenly went viral after their song was removed from digital platforms, sparking widespread protests from the public. This incident caught the attention of many, including senior musician Melly Goeslaw, who ultimately expressed her opinion through Instagram.

In her post on February 24, 2025, Melly Goeslaw shared a photo of the band Sukatani with a lengthy caption containing her views on this controversy. She highlighted the difference between explicit lyrics and protest lyrics as used by Sukatani.

"Honestly, I didn’t know this song, I became aware of it after it went viral because it was taken down from the platform, and then the public protested," wrote Melly Goeslaw in her post on Instagram @melly_goeslaw.

1. The Difference Between Explicit Lyrics and Social Critique in Music

Melly Goeslaw Speaks Out Regarding the Band Sukatani (credit: instagram/melly_goeslaw)

Melly Goeslaw emphasizes that there is a fundamental difference between songs with explicit lyrics and songs that contain social critique.

According to her, explicit lyrics are often considered vulgar or inappropriate, while songs like those performed by Sukatani aim to convey a message of critique against an institution.

"This is certainly different from what the band Sukatani does. Sukatani's lyrics are a reflection of protest directed at a state institution," said Melly.

2. Controversy Over Song Removal and Public Reaction

Melly Goeslaw Voices Her Opinion Regarding the Sukatani Band (credit: instagram/melly_goeslaw)

The song by Sukatani was temporarily removed from digital platforms, which then sparked a significant reaction from the public.

Melly Goeslaw admitted that she only learned about the song after it went viral due to its removal. She sees that this actually elevated the song to a wider public audience.

"On the positive side, more people are becoming aware of this song, so the lyrics written for critique are becoming more resonant," she added.

3. The Stance of Relevant Institutions and Final Decision

Melly Goeslaw Voices Her Opinion Regarding the Sukatani Band (credit: instagram/melly_goeslaw)

After facing criticism, the institution targeted by the song finally provided clarification and allowed the song to circulate again.

Melly believes that criticism through music can be a means to foster better discussions, as long as it adheres to the prevailing ethics and rules.

"I hope the criticism through the lyrics of the song becomes constructive criticism and leads to better changes in the future," she explained.

4. The Case of the Dismissal of Novi Citra Indriyati as a Teacher

Melly Goeslaw Also Speaks Out Regarding the Band Sukatani (credit: instagram/melly_goeslaw)

In addition to the controversy over the song, another issue that has emerged is the news that Novi Citra Indriyati, the vocalist of the band Sukatani, has been dismissed from her job as a teacher.

Melly Goeslaw hopes that the news is not true, but she understands that schools have their own policies and codes of ethics that must be followed.

"As far as I know, that school has its own policies. And Novi was dismissed from her duties as a teacher because, according to the school, she violated the code of ethics related to Islamic law," wrote Melly.

5. The Importance of Freedom to Create Wisely

At the end of her statement, Melly Goeslaw emphasized the importance of freedom of expression in creating, but still within the bounds of applicable rules.

She reminded that intelligent artists know how to convey messages in a way that remains ethical and engaging without causing misunderstandings.

"Sukatani packages its work quite beautifully, even though it initially caused less than beautiful communication between them and the institution," she said.

6. What caused the Sukatani band's song to be removed from the platform?

The Sukatani song was removed because it was deemed to contain criticism against a state institution, but it was eventually allowed back after clarification.

7. What is Melly Goeslaw's stance on this case?

Melly Goeslaw supports artistic freedom but emphasizes that artists must be wise in conveying messages to avoid misunderstandings.

Want to read more news related to Melly Goeslaw? Let's read now at KapanLagi.com. If not now, when?

(kpl/sjn)