4 Controversial Religious Films in Indonesia That Sparked Debate in Their Time

Films with religious themes often attract attention, especially when presenting stories that provoke debate. Some of them raise sensitive issues that stir the public, even triggering controversy. In Indonesia, there are also several controversial religious films that sparked intense debate in society.

These controversial religious films faced various obstacles, ranging from protests to bans on screenings. However, it is precisely from these controversies that deep messages and social critiques are often conveyed. The directors and production teams dare to explore issues that are rarely discussed, making these works still interesting to talk about. Curious about what films they are?

Here is a review of several controversial religious films in Indonesia that were debated.

1. THE WOMAN WITH THE TURBAN (2009)

WOMAN WITH A TURBAN (credit: imdb)

The film THE WOMAN WITH THE TURBAN is adapted from a novel by Abidah El Khalieqy and tells the story of a woman’s life within a conservative pesantren tradition. THE WOMAN WITH THE TURBAN narrates the story of Annisa, a woman who must submit to male dominance, reflecting patriarchal views in several teachings. Set in a pesantren in East Java, this film presents a social critique on the role of women in a religious environment.

Starring Revalina S. Temat, Reza Rahadian, and Oka Antara, this film sparked heated discussions in society. The pesantren tradition, which is considered too conservative towards women, became the main focus, leading to protests from various groups. Even the Indonesian Ulema Council (MUI) suggested that the film be withdrawn from circulation.

Screened in various cinemas in Indonesia, THE WOMAN WITH THE TURBAN still received appreciation for its bravery in addressing sensitive issues. Despite being controversial, this film successfully conveys the message about the importance of gender equality.

2. ? (QUESTION MARK) (2011)

? (QUESTION MARK) (credit: imdb)

? (QUESTION MARK) is a film directed by Hanung Bramantyo that explores the interactions of three families from different religious backgrounds: Buddhism, Islam, and Catholicism. ? presents a story of everyday life filled with conflicts, including the violence and discrimination they experience. The storyline is inspired by the director's personal experiences as a child of mixed descent.

The production process of this film was not easy due to the sensitive themes addressed. Hanung faced difficulties in obtaining funding and encountered protests after the film was released. The film received criticism from MUI and FPI, who deemed its story to violate several religious teachings.

Nevertheless, ? was still shown in theaters and sparked heated discussions. This film offers a new perspective on interfaith harmony that is full of challenges in real life.

3. A THREATENING PRAYER (2008)

THREATENING PRAYER (credit: imdb)

The story of Madrim, a desperate porter, is the core of the narrative A THREATENING PRAYER. Madrim, played by Aming, feels that his life is always plagued by misfortune. In his despair, he gives an ultimatum to God: if his prayer is not answered within three days, he will turn to the devil.

This film by Hanung Bramantyo has sparked controversy for allegedly misusing the meaning of prayer in Islam. Some circles view its story as deviating from religious values. However, Aming's total acting has received praise, adding emotional depth to the character of Madrim.

Screened in theaters, A THREATENING PRAYER successfully conveys a message about human despair and the struggle to face life's challenges. This film has become a topic of discussion about the meaning of prayer and the relationship between humans and God.

4. CLAIMING TO BE A PROPHET (2008)

CLAIMING TO BE A PROPHET (credit: starvision)

This controversial religious film, CLAIMING TO BE A PROPHET, tells the story of a hermitage in West Java that serves as a front for a cult. In CLAIMING TO BE A PROPHET, a teacher claims to be a prophet sent by God and promises the forgiveness of sins through the purchase of certificates. This story illustrates how religion can be misused for worldly interests.

Directed by Hefli Kardit, this film stars Ray Sahetapy and Reza Pahlevi. The screening of this film received protests from MUI as it was deemed to deviate from Islamic teachings. Despite its controversy, this film opens the audience's eyes to the dangers of the misuse of religion.

Screened in Indonesia, CLAIMING TO BE A PROPHET provides relevant social criticism regarding the phenomenon of cults that are rampant in society. Its story touches on important issues that are rarely brought to the big screen.

These are among some of the controversial religious films in Indonesia. These films not only provide entertainment but also serve as a medium to convey social criticism and raise sensitive issues. The accompanying controversy shows how powerful the influence of film is as a communication medium.

Find reviews and synopses of other interesting films at kapanlagi.com. If not now, when?

(kpl/psp)